For a class debate, Aisha's group compares two global problems using only facts from their science book.
| Ozone hole | Rising carbon dioxide | |
|---|---|---|
| Main cause | CFCs used in refrigerators and aerosols | burning fossil fuels, deforestation |
| Where the effect was severe or is measured | severe ozone loss over Antarctica | carbon dioxide in the air: 315 ppm in 1960, now about 420 ppm |
| Global agreement | Montreal Protocol | Kyoto Protocol, Paris Agreement |
| Present state | ozone layer slowly recovering | still rising; agreements less successful |
(i) What did CFCs do to the ozone layer, and why is this harmful to living things?
(ii) CFCs came from a few kinds of products, such as refrigerators and aerosol sprays. Carbon dioxide comes from burning fuels for electricity, transport and industry. Use this to explain why the carbon dioxide problem is much harder to solve than the ozone problem.
(iii) India has planted billions of trees. Explain how planting trees reduces the carbon dioxide in the air, and why planting trees alone cannot solve the problem if the burning of fossil fuels keeps increasing.
