(i) The room light lets him see the ball, and at X, Y and Z the whole white half faces him. So the ball looks like a full Moon every time; the shape of the white part never changes.
(ii) The Moon does not emit light of its own; it shines because it reflects sunlight. The half that is lit is the half that faces the Sun, not the half that faces the Earth. In Arjun's model the "lit" half always faces the Earth (him), and nothing in the model plays the part of the Sun lighting one side, so the model cannot show the changing fraction of the lit half that we see.
(iii) He should use an unpainted ball on a stick and a torch or lamp (about 3 m away) as the Sun, with his head as the Earth. He should hold the ball at arm's length, slightly above his head, and turn slowly anticlockwise. Then the lamp lights the half of the ball facing it, and as the ball's position changes with respect to the lamp he sees a different part of the lit half: none of it when the ball is towards the lamp (new Moon), all of it when the ball is opposite the lamp (full Moon), and curved shapes in between.