(i) 80:9::200: ?. The factor of change is 80200=25, so 200 guests need
9×25=22.5 kg
(ii) She needs at least 22.5 kg. These are all the ways of buying at least 22.5 kg in which no bag could be left out:
| bags | rice | cost |
|---|
| 3 of 10 kg | 30 kg | ₹1,950 |
| 2 of 10 kg + 1 of 5 kg | 25 kg | ₹1,640 |
| 1 of 10 kg + 3 of 5 kg | 25 kg | ₹1,670 |
| 5 of 5 kg | 25 kg | ₹1,700 |
The cheapest is 2 bags of 10 kg and 1 bag of 5 kg, for 2×650+340=1640, that is ₹1,640. (A 10 kg bag works out at ₹65 per kg and a 5 kg bag at ₹68 per kg, so she uses as many 10 kg bags as she can.)
(iii) Charge for 144 guests =2000+150×144=2000+21600=23600, that is ₹23,600.
Charge for 200 guests =2000+150×200=2000+30000=32000, that is ₹32,000.
Check 144:23600 against 200:32000 by cross multiplication:
144×32000=46,08,000and23600×200=47,20,000
The products are not equal, so the charge is not proportional to the number of guests. The fixed ₹2,000 is paid whatever the number of guests, so the bill does not grow by the same factor as the guests. The secretary is wrong.