(i) In the six numbers, each digit is in the hundreds place twice, in the tens place twice and in the ones place twice. By place value, the total is
2(a+b+c)×100+2(a+b+c)×10+2(a+b+c)=222(a+b+c)
(ii) 222(a+b+c)=3330, so a+b+c=3330÷222=15. Two possible sets: 1, 5, 9 and 2, 6, 7 (others are 1, 6, 8 or 3, 4, 8, and so on).
(iii) With 0, 4, 9 only four numbers are real 3-digit numbers: 409, 490, 904, 940.
409+490+904+940=2743
Sid's true total is 2743. But 222×13=2886, and 2743÷222 is not a whole number (222×12=2664). The formula counted the two "numbers" 049 and 094, which are not 3-digit numbers:
2886−49−94=2743
So the trick breaks when one of the digits is 0: each digit is no longer in every place twice.