In the demonstration of passing electricity through water, the gas in Ritu's tube burns with a pop. She says, "So water must have bubbles of hydrogen gas mixed in it, just as soda water has a gas mixed in it."
Which reply to Ritu is the best?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 24 of 40
In the demonstration of passing electricity through water, the gas in Ritu's tube burns with a pop. She says, "So water must have bubbles of hydrogen gas mixed in it, just as soda water has a gas mixed in it."
Which reply to Ritu is the best?
(A) No. In water, hydrogen is combined chemically with oxygen; it is set free only when water breaks down.
(B) Yes. Water is just a mixture of hydrogen gas and oxygen gas, in exactly the same way as soda water is.
(C) No. The hydrogen came out of the battery itself, and the water had nothing to do with it.
(D) Yes. Simply boiling the water would also set free these hydrogen bubbles that are hidden in it.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
Water is a compound. In water, the particles of hydrogen and oxygen are so tightly attached to each other that they cannot be separated by physical methods. Hydrogen and oxygen gases appear only when water breaks down as electricity passes through it.
Soda water is different: it is a mixture (gas and liquid) in which the gas is simply mixed into the water and keeps its own properties.
Why the other options are wrong