After watching sugar being heated in a boiling tube, Rehaan says, "Sugar gave black charcoal and drops of water, so sugar is just a mixture of charcoal and water."
Give two arguments against Rehaan's claim.
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 32 of 40
After watching sugar being heated in a boiling tube, Rehaan says, "Sugar gave black charcoal and drops of water, so sugar is just a mixture of charcoal and water."
Give two arguments against Rehaan's claim.
Argument 1 (properties): In a mixture, each substance retains its properties. Sugar is white, sweet and dry; it shows neither the black colour of charcoal nor the wetness of water. Its properties are different from those of the substances it gives on heating. That is what we expect for a compound, because the properties of compounds are different from those of the elements forming them.
Argument 2 (separation): The components of a mixture can be separated by physical methods. Charcoal and water cannot be got out of sugar by any physical method; dissolving sugar in water and letting the water evaporate gives back only sugar. Carbon and water appear only when sugar decomposes on heating. As water consists of hydrogen and oxygen, sugar is a compound of carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen, not a mixture of charcoal and water.