Mohit wants to know whether brand X or brand Y mustard seeds pop sooner in his tadka. He uses the same amount of oil and seeds each time, on the same flame. His notebook is shown below.

Which statement is best?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 25 of 40
Mohit wants to know whether brand X or brand Y mustard seeds pop sooner in his tadka. He uses the same amount of oil and seeds each time, on the same flame. His notebook is shown below.

Which statement is best?
(A) Brand X popped sooner, so brand X seeds must be fresher than the brand Y ones
(B) Brand Y is better, because its oil splattered less in the kadhai
(C) His notes are useless, because they contain too many extra details
(D) He can't credit the brand alone; his notes show the kadhai changed too
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Mohit meant to change only the brand. But his notes show that trial 2 also used a different kadhai (the small one). So two things changed: the brand and the kadhai. The 15-second difference (35 s − 20 s) could be due to either, so he cannot credit it to the brand alone.
The book asks us to "keep notes of everything that you see and sense". Writing down the small detail about the kadhai is exactly what let him notice the problem. He should repeat both brands in the same kadhai.
Why the other options are wrong