Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 35 of 40

A Class 7 group in Shimla sets up four bottles with iron nails and leaves them for 10 days.

Question 353 marksHard

A Class 7 group in Shimla sets up four bottles with iron nails and leaves them for 10 days. The figure shows the set-ups and the table gives the results.

Four bottles: A capped with silica gel; B capped with boiled water and an oil layer; C with no cap and a nail partly in water; D capped with a nail lying on wet cotton

BottleSet-upAfter 10 days
Acapped; dry, with silica gelno brown deposit
Bcapped; nail fully under freshly boiled and cooled water, with a layer of oilno brown deposit
Cno cap; nail partly in waterbrown deposit
Dcapped; nail lying on a pad of wet cotton wool, the rest of the bottle full of airbrown deposit

(i) Bottle D was capped tightly, yet its nail rusted. Explain why.

(ii) The group sets up one more bottle, E, exactly like B but with no cap. Predict whether its nail will get brown deposits, and give the reason.

(iii) Which two bottles in the table, taken together, show that it was the lack of water, and not the cap, that kept the nail in bottle A clean? Explain.