After the red-ink twig activity with white sadabahar twigs, four students each write what the activity proves. Whose conclusion is supported by this activity alone?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 27 of 40
After the red-ink twig activity with white sadabahar twigs, four students each write what the activity proves.
- Correct answer
(A) Arnav: water, with things dissolved in it, moves up the stem to leaves and flowers in thin tubes.
(B) Bina: the food that is made in the leaves is carried down to the roots through the phloem tubes.
(C) Chetan: the minerals that a plant needs for its growth are made inside its own leaves and flowers.
(D) Divya: the plant used the red ink to make its own food, and that is why its flowers turned red.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
In the activity, red colour appears in the stem, leaves and flowers of the twig standing in red-ink water, and a cut through the upper stem shows the red colour inside it. This shows only that water, with the ink dissolved in it, moves up the stem to the leaves and flowers through thin tube-like structures (the xylem). Arnav's conclusion is supported.
Why the other options are wrong
- (B) Food moving through the phloem is true, but the twig activity does not test food at all; it only follows coloured water moving up.
- (C) Minerals are not made in the leaves. They come from the soil and are taken up by the roots with water.
- (D) The ink only travels up with the water. Food is made from carbon dioxide and water in sunlight, not from red ink.
