Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Each piece must have 6÷2=3 squares, and each piece must stay in one part.
In slab (D), the square in the centre of the cross touches four squares. The left square, the right square and the top square each touch only the centre square. So whichever piece contains the centre square must also contain the left, right and top squares, or else those squares would be cut off on their own. That piece would have at least 4 squares, but each piece must have 3. So slab (D) cannot be broken into two congruent pieces.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) The two squares of the top row with the first square of the middle row form an L of 3 squares. The other three squares (the last two of the middle row and the bottom square) form the same L, so one piece fits on the other just by sliding it.
- (B) The top-left square with the first two squares of the long row make an L of 3 squares; the last two squares of the row with the bottom-right square make another L. A half turn takes one onto the other.
- (C) Break between the second and third rows: the top two rows give an L of 3 squares and the bottom two rows give an identical L, which fits on the first without any turning.