Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
Pieces are congruent if each one can be laid exactly over the others, after turning or flipping it if needed. Having the same number of squares is not enough; the pieces must have the same shape too.
In way (A) the four pieces are:
- top left: three squares in a row with one square below the left end (an L-shape);
- top right: three squares in a column with one square sticking out from the middle (a T-shape);
- middle left: two pairs of squares shifted by one square (a zig-zag, or S-shape);
- bottom right: another T-shape.
An L-shape, a T-shape and a zig-zag cannot be laid on each other however we turn or flip them. So in way (A) the pieces are not all congruent, and the friends do not get identical pieces.
Why the other options are wrong
- (B) All four pieces are straight strips of 4 squares (1 × 4). They fit exactly on each other.
- (C) All four pieces are 2 × 2 squares. They fit exactly on each other.
- (D) All four pieces are T-shapes. Each piece is the next one turned through a quarter turn, so turning one piece makes it fit exactly on any other.