(i) On 1 unit = 10 quintals, the tallest column is 160÷10=16 units. 16 is more than 12, so no, it will not fit.
For the 160-quintal column to fit, 160 ÷ (scale) must be at most 12.
- 1 unit = 13: 160÷13=12134 units, which is more than 12, so it does not fit.
- 1 unit = 14: 160÷14=1173 units, which fits.
The smallest whole-number scale that fits is 1 unit = 14 quintals. So any scale that fits must be 14 or more.
(ii) A column ends on a whole-unit or half-unit line when its length is a whole number of half units. One half unit stands for half the scale, so twice the value must be a whole number of scales: the scale must be a factor of 2×45=90, 2×75=150, 2×120=240 and 2×160=320.
The common factors of 90 and 150 are 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 10, 15 and 30. Of these, 3, 6, 15 and 30 are not factors of 320 (320÷3, 320÷6, 320÷15 and 320÷30 are not whole numbers). So the only scales that make every column end on a whole or half unit are 1, 2, 5 and 10 quintals per unit.
All of these are less than 14, so none of them fits on the paper (even 1 unit = 10 needs 16 units). Neha cannot have both wishes. She must either use taller paper (16 units, with 1 unit = 10 quintals) or accept a column that ends between the half-unit lines (for example, 1 unit = 15 quintals gives 3, 8, 5 and 1032 units).