After watching the churning painting at the Bhopal dhaba, Malli has an idea: "If churning can take butter out of curd, I can churn salt water with a mathni to take the salt out!"
Why will Malli's idea not work?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 26 of 40
After watching the churning painting at the Bhopal dhaba, Malli has an idea: "If churning can take butter out of curd, I can churn salt water with a mathni to take the salt out!"
Why will Malli's idea not work?
(A) Salt is much heavier than butter, so Malli only needs to churn the salt water for a much longer time
(B) Churning works only in clay pots, and salt water is kept in steel vessels
(C) Churning can separate only things that are white in colour, such as butter
(D) Butter does not dissolve, so it gathers and floats; salt is dissolved, so it never collects
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
In churning, the butter being lighter floats at the top, while the buttermilk is left behind. This works because butter is not dissolved in the curd: churning makes it gather into lumps that float.
In salt water, the salt is dissolved. It is spread all through the water and never gathers into lumps, so there is nothing that can float up or be lifted off. To get dissolved salt back, the water must be removed by evaporation, which is used to separate a solid dissolved in a liquid.
Why the other options are wrong