At midnight in Nubra, Yangdol and Dorjay see three bright points of light high in the sky. Point P twinkles a lot. Point Q shines steadily. Point R twinkles a lot. Dorjay says, "One of these must be Venus." Which statement is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 28 of 40
At midnight in Nubra, Yangdol and Dorjay see three bright points of light high in the sky.
(A) P is Venus, because Venus is the brightest object in the sky after the Sun and the Moon.
- Correct answer
(B) Q is probably a planet but not Venus; it could be Mars, Jupiter or Saturn.
(C) Q is Venus, because planets do not twinkle a lot the way that stars do.
(D) None of them is a planet, because planets can never be seen in the sky at midnight.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
Stars appear to twinkle a lot; planets do not. So P and R are stars, and the steady point Q is probably a planet.
But Q cannot be Venus. Venus is seen at dawn (near the East before sunrise) or at dusk (near the West after sunset), not high in the sky at midnight. Other planets - Mercury, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn - can also be seen with the naked eye and look like shining dots, so Q could be one of them, such as Mars, Jupiter or Saturn.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) P twinkles a lot, so it is a star, not a planet. Also Venus is seen at dawn or dusk, not at midnight.
- (C) Not twinkling does show that Q is likely a planet, but it does not make it Venus. Venus is seen only near dawn or dusk.
- (D) Planets such as Mars, Jupiter and Saturn can be seen with the naked eye at night. A steady point like Q is likely to be one of them.
