On a moonless evening in January, just after sunset, Ira sees the bright star Sirius in the east and Venus low in the west. Her brother says, "Sirius is the brightest star in the night sky, so it must be the brightest thing in the sky right now." Which statement is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 25 of 40
On a moonless evening in January, just after sunset, Ira sees the bright star Sirius in the east and Venus low in the…
(A) Her brother is right, because a star always shines more brightly than any planet can.
(B) Sirius and Venus look equally bright, because both of them shine with their own light.
- Correct answer
(C) Venus looks brighter, as after the Sun and the Moon it is the brightest object in the sky.
(D) Neither of them can be seen yet, because stars and planets never show up just after sunset.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation:
Sirius is the brightest star in the night sky - but Venus is not a star. The book says that after the Sun and the Moon, Venus is the brightest object in the sky. The Sun has set and there is no Moon, so Venus is the brightest thing Ira can see, brighter than Sirius. "Brightest star" and "brightest object" are not the same thing.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) A star does not always look brighter than a planet. Venus looks brighter than every star, including Sirius.
- (B) The Sun produces almost all the energy in the Solar System; Venus does not make its own light but shines by reflecting sunlight. Also, the two do not look equally bright.
- (D) Venus is usually seen shining brightly at dusk, near the West just after sunset, so it can be seen at this time.
