On their morning walk, Avadhi and Aayush find a snail in its shell on a wet stone. They watch it for ten minutes and it does not move at all. Aayush says, "It is not moving, so it must be non-living."
Which is the best reply to Aayush?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 2 of 40
On their morning walk, Avadhi and Aayush find a snail in its shell on a wet stone. They watch it for ten minutes and it does not move at all. Aayush says, "It is not moving, so it must be non-living."
Which is the best reply to Aayush?
(A) You are right, because anything that stays still for ten minutes cannot be living
(B) The shell is non-living, so whatever is inside the shell must be non-living too
(C) The snail is a living being only at the times when it comes out of its shell and moves about
(D) The shell is part of a living snail's body; resting does not make it non-living
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
In the chapter, Avadhi's mother explains that the shell could be home to a living snail and is actually a part of its body. A living snail may stay still for a long time inside its shell.
To decide whether something is living, we check all the features of living beings together. The snail eats, grows, breathes and produces young ones, even if it is resting at this moment. Not moving for ten minutes does not make it non-living.
Why the other options are wrong