(i) Kabir changed more than one condition at a time. Seedling 2 gets no light and also no water. If seedling 2 grows badly, he cannot tell whether it is because of the dark or because it was not watered. Also, seedling 2 gets no light at all, so it cannot show which way the shoot grows towards light.
(ii) Both seedlings should be watered the same way, be of the same kind and size, and be kept in the same sunny place. The only difference should be the direction of light: seedling 1 in the box with a hole on one side, and seedling 2 open, getting light from all directions.
(iii) Seedling 1: the shoot will bend and grow towards the hole (the light), while the root continues to grow downwards. Seedling 2: the shoot grows straight upwards and the root grows downwards. Comparing the two shows that shoots grow towards light.