Which of these people is not following the scientific method?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 25 of 40
Which of these people is not following the scientific method?
(A) A mechanic guesses that a wire in a scooter is loose, tightens it and tries to start the scooter
(B) Dadi guesses that the sabzi needs more salt, adds a pinch and tastes it again before serving
- Correct answer
(C) A shopkeeper's freezer stops cooling; he says it is too old and buys a new one without checking
(D) Leela guesses her plant needs more light, moves it to the window and watches it for a week
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation:
Following the scientific method means we observe, wonder, guess a possible answer, test the guess through experiments or more observations, and analyse the results.
The shopkeeper made a guess ("it is too old") but never tested it. He did not check the plug, the switch or anything else. He treated his guess as if it were the answer, so he is not following the scientific method. The freezer may have had a small fault that was easy to fix.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) The mechanic guessed (a loose wire) and tested it by tightening the wire and trying to start the scooter. He is following the method.
- (B) Dadi guessed (more salt) and tested it by tasting again. She is following the method.
- (D) Leela guessed (more light), tested it by moving the plant, and is making more observations for a week. She is following the method.
