On Monday, Pinky wore her new blue shoes to school, and it rained in the afternoon. She tells her friends, "My blue shoes bring rain!"
(i) What is wrong with the way Pinky reached this idea?
(ii) How can Pinky test her idea by more observations?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 13 of 40
On Monday, Pinky wore her new blue shoes to school, and it rained in the afternoon. She tells her friends, "My blue shoes bring rain!"
(i) What is wrong with the way Pinky reached this idea?
(ii) How can Pinky test her idea by more observations?
(i) Pinky saw it happen only once. "My blue shoes bring rain" is only a guess, but she has treated it as if it were already proved. In the scientific method, a guess must be tested through experiments or more observations, and the results must be analysed, before we can say whether it is right. One rainy Monday is not enough.
(ii) She can keep a record for many days, for example for the whole monsoon month. Each day she writes down (1) whether she wore the blue shoes and (2) whether it rained. Then she compares the days. If it rained just as often on days she wore other shoes, and some days she wore the blue shoes with no rain, her guess is not right.