(i) No. Her guess is about the fridge door, but she changed the shop and left the door just as it was. If the new milk stays good, she will not know whether it was because of the shop. If it goes bad, she still has not checked the door. So this test cannot tell her whether her guess is right.
(ii) She should test the door itself. For example, get the door fixed so that it closes properly (or check that it shuts tightly every time), then keep the same kind of milk from the same shop in the fridge and see whether it stays good for longer than before. If it does, the result supports her guess. If it still goes bad just as quickly, she should make another guess.