Kabir does the tile activity. He keeps the black tile in the Sun and the white tile under a tree, as shown.

After an hour he touches both and says, "The white tile is cooler. This proves white surfaces stay cooler." What is wrong with his test?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 23 of 40
Kabir does the tile activity. He keeps the black tile in the Sun and the white tile under a tree, as shown.

After an hour he touches both and says, "The white tile is cooler. This proves white surfaces stay cooler." What is wrong with his test?
(A) Both tiles should be in the Sun; the shade may have kept the white tile cool.
(B) He should have used two black tiles so that both tiles were exactly the same.
(C) He should have kept both tiles in the shade so that neither of them got hot.
(D) He should have touched them after one minute, as one hour is far too long.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
In the activity, both tiles are kept under the Sun. Only one thing is different: the colour. Then any difference we feel must be because of the colour.
In Kabir's test two things are different: the colour and the place. Trees that give shade keep things cool, so the white tile may be cooler just because it was in the shade. His test cannot show what the colour alone does.
Why the other options are wrong