Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 1 of 80
Two statements are given below. One is labelled Assertion
Question 11 markMCQMedium
Two statements are given below. One is labelled Assertion (A) and the other is labelled Reason (R). Read the statements carefully and choose the option that correctly describes statements A and R.
Assertion (A): If the two slits of a double-slit arrangement are lit by the left and right halves of the same sodium lamp (instead of through one narrow source slit), no steady fringes are seen.
Reason (R): Light from different parts of an extended source comes from different atoms, whose phases change randomly and independently, so the two waves are not coherent.
Select your answer
(A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
Correct answer
(B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(C) A is true, but R is false.
(D) A is false, but R is true.
Option (A) is correct.
Concept used — coherent sources
Two sources give a steady interference pattern only if they are coherent: they have the same frequency and a phase difference ϕ that stays constant in time. The intensity where their waves meet is
I=I1+I2+2I1I2cosϕ
If ϕ changes randomly and very fast, cosϕ averages to zero, and the eye sees only I1+I2: uniform illumination with no fringes.
Step 1 — Judge the Assertion. The left and right halves of a sodium lamp are two separate collections of emitting atoms. The waves reaching the two slits therefore come from different atoms, and their phase difference changes randomly in times of the order of 10−10 s. The fringes would shift just as fast, so the eye sees only the average, uniform brightness. No steady fringes are seen, so A is true.
Step 2 — Judge the Reason. Each atom emits light in short bursts whose phases are random and independent of the bursts from other atoms. So light from different parts of an extended source has no fixed phase relation: the two waves are not coherent. R is true.
Step 3 — Does R explain A? Yes. A states that no steady fringes form, and R gives the cause: the waves at the two slits come from different atoms, so ϕ is not constant and the cosϕ term averages to zero. In Young's arrangement, by contrast, a single narrow slit lights both S1 and S2, so any change of phase at the source reaches both slits together and ϕ stays fixed. R is the correct explanation of A.
Answer: both A and R are true, and R explains A, so option (A).
Why the others fail: (B) would need R to be true but unrelated to A, whereas incoherence is exactly why the fringes vanish. (C) and (D) each call a true statement false.