(a) In a chemical reaction the number of atoms of each element is the same on both sides; the atoms are only rearranged. In a nuclear reaction the atoms themselves change, but the total number of nucleons (A) and the total charge (Z) are the same on both sides. In reactions with no β-decay step, such as the fission of uranium or D-T fusion, the numbers of protons and of neutrons are separately conserved as well; in β-decay (and in the proton–proton cycle, where protons turn into neutrons) only their total is conserved. Mass is balanced in neither: in both kinds of reaction the total rest mass changes by c2Q.
(b) Per molecule:
Δm=931.5×106 eV/u2.96 eV=3.2×10−9 u
Per mole:
E=2.96×1.6×10−19×6.02×1023=2.85×105 J,Δm=c2E=9×10162.85×105=3.2×10−12 kg
That is about 3 nanograms in every 18 g of water formed.
(c) Water:
mΔm=183.2×10−9=1.8×10−10
D-T fusion:
Δm=931.517.6=0.0189 u,mΔm=5.0300.0189=3.8×10−3
The fractional mass change in the nuclear reaction is about 1.8×10−103.8×10−3=2×107 times larger.
(d) The student is wrong. The energy released in a chemical reaction also comes from a loss of mass, the change in the binding of electrons in the atoms and molecules, exactly as E=Δmc2 says. But chemical binding energies are a few eV, while nuclear ones are MeV, so the chemical mass change is only about 2 parts in 1010. The best balances cannot detect 3 ng in 18 g, so mass appears to be conserved in chemistry. In nuclear reactions the change is about 0.4 %, easily measured.