Concept used — Coulomb's law and Newton's law of gravitation
Two point charges q1, q2 a distance r apart repel or attract with the Coulomb force, and two masses m1, m2 attract with the gravitational force:
FC=4πε01r2q1q2,FG=Gr2m1m2
Each proton carries charge e and mass mp, so both laws apply to the same pair. Both forces fall off as r21, so their ratio does not depend on the separation.
Given: r=1.0 fm =1.0×10−15 m, 4πε01=9×109 N m² C⁻², e=1.6×10−19 C, G=6.67×10−11 N m² kg⁻², mp=1.67×10−27 kg.
(a)
Step 1 — Coulomb force. Put q1=q2=e:
FC=(1.0×10−15)29×109×(1.6×10−19)2=1.0×10−309×109×2.56×10−38
FC=1.0×10−302.30×10−28≈230 N
Both charges are positive, so this force is repulsive.
Step 2 — Gravitational force. Put m1=m2=mp:
FG=(1.0×10−15)26.67×10−11×(1.67×10−27)2=1.0×10−306.67×10−11×2.79×10−54
FG=1.0×10−301.86×10−64≈1.9×10−34 N
Gravity is always attractive.
Step 3 — Ratio of the two forces.
FGFC=1.86×10−34230≈1.2×1036
Answer: FC≈230 N (repulsive), FG≈1.9×10−34 N (attractive), and FGFC≈1.2×1036.
(b)
Step 1 — Compare the forces. The two protons push each other apart with about 230 N, an enormous force on particles of mass 10−27 kg, while gravity pulls them together with a force about 1036 times weaker. Gravity cannot hold the protons together.
Step 2 — Conclude. If these were the only forces, the protons would fly apart and no nucleus with more than one proton could exist. Nuclei are stable, so there must be a third force acting between nucleons.
Answer: there must be an attractive nuclear force between nucleons, and at separations of about 1 fm it must be stronger than the Coulomb repulsion (and so vastly stronger than gravity).
Note: the ratio FC/FG is the same at every separation, because both forces go as r21. Gravity is negligible inside nuclei at any distance.