Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 39 of 80
(a) According to classical electromagnetic theory, why should the electron in Rutherford's model of the hydrogen atom…
Question 393 marksEasy
(a) According to classical electromagnetic theory, why should the electron in Rutherford's model of the hydrogen atom radiate energy?
(b) Using rmv2=4πε0r2e2, show how the frequency of revolution depends on r. How does this frequency change as the electron loses energy?
(c) Explain why this picture predicts a continuous spectrum and an unstable atom, contrary to what is observed.
(a) An electron moving in a circle is always accelerating towards the centre, because the direction of its velocity keeps changing. Classical electromagnetic theory says that an accelerating charge radiates electromagnetic waves, so the orbiting electron should keep giving out energy.
(b) From the force equation, v=4πε0mre2. The frequency of revolution is
f=2πrv=2π14πε0me2r−3/2
so f∝r−3/2. The total energy is E=−8πε0re2. As the electron radiates, E becomes more negative, so r must decrease; and as r decreases, f increases.
(c) The electron would follow a spiral path inwards towards the nucleus:
Classically, the frequency of the radiation equals the frequency of revolution. As the electron spirals in, f rises smoothly and continuously, so the atom would give out every frequency over a range: a continuous spectrum. The electron would also end up in the nucleus, so the atom would collapse. Real hydrogen atoms are stable and emit only a line spectrum, so this classical picture cannot be correct for electrons in atoms.