Two thin foils, one of gold () and one of aluminium (), contain the same number of nuclei per unit area. The same beam of α-particles, all of the same kinetic energy, falls on each. Which foil gives more α-particles scattered through large angles, and why?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 28 of 80
Two thin foils, one of gold ( Z = 79 ) and one of aluminium ( Z = 13 ), contain the same number of nuclei per unit area.
(A) Aluminium, because a lighter nucleus is pushed aside more easily and so deflects the α-particle more.
(B) Neither; the number scattered through large angles depends only on the kinetic energy of the α-particles.
(C) Aluminium, because an α-particle can get about 6 times closer to an aluminium nucleus.
- Correct answer
(D) Gold, because its nucleus repels about 6 times more strongly at the same distance.
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: The force between an α-particle and a nucleus is
At every point along the path, the force from a gold nucleus is times the force from an aluminium nucleus at the same distance. An α-particle aimed at a given distance from the nucleus (the same impact parameter) is therefore pushed much harder by gold and turned through a larger angle. Particles that pass gold nuclei at larger distances can still be turned through large angles, so more large-angle scattering is seen with gold. This is why a heavy element was chosen for the foil.
- (A) is wrong: the heavy gold nucleus hardly moves and so pushes back on the α-particle fully; a light nucleus recoils and takes up some of the energy, which makes large-angle scattering less, not more.
- (B) ignores the charge of the target, which sets the strength of the force.
- (C) is true only for a head-on approach: , so the α-particle does get closer to aluminium. But for the same aiming distance, the force from aluminium is always about 6 times weaker, so the deflection is smaller.
