A spherical Gaussian surface S encloses two point charges and . A third charge is placed outside the surface.
At a certain point P on the Gaussian surface, the net electric field is found to be zero.
A student makes the following statements:
- Since the electric field at P is zero, the total electric flux through the Gaussian surface must also be zero.
- The external charge contributes to the electric field at points on the Gaussian surface but makes no net contribution to the total flux through it.
- If the external charge is moved closer to the Gaussian surface without crossing it, the total electric flux through the surface remains unchanged.
(a) Identify which of the above statements are correct and which are incorrect. Justify each answer.
(b) Calculate the total electric flux through the Gaussian surface.
(c) If the charge is moved outside the Gaussian surface while all other charges remain at their positions, determine the new total electric flux through the surface.

