Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 63 of 80
Two charges +Q are fixed at x = -a and x = +a .
Question 633 marksMedium
Two charges +Q are fixed at x=−a and x=+a. A small bead of mass m and charge +q can slide without friction along a straight insulating wire lying along the x-axis.
(a) Where is the bead in equilibrium? Is the equilibrium stable for displacements along the wire?
(b) Show that for a small displacement x≪a the bead performs SHM, and find its time period.
(c) If the wire is removed, is the equilibrium stable for a small displacement perpendicular to the x-axis? Explain.
(a) At the midpointx=0 the two repulsions are equal and opposite — equilibrium. Push the bead towards one charge and that charge's repulsion grows while the other's weakens: the net force pushes it back. So it is stable along the wire.
(b) At position x (towards the right-hand charge), the net force is
F=(a+x)2kQq−(a−x)2kQq
For x≪a, use (a±x)−2≈a21(1∓a2x):
F≈a2kQq[(1−a2x)−(1+a2x)]=−a34kQqx
The force is proportional to the displacement and opposite to it — SHM, with ω2=ma34kQq:
T=2π4kQqma3=πkQqma3
(c)No — it is unstable. Move the bead a little to (0,y). Each charge now pushes it along a line tilted slightly away from the x-axis, and both forces have a component pointing further away in the y-direction. Nothing pulls it back, so it flies off. The equilibrium is stable along the line of the charges but unstable across it — a saddle. (This is a general result: stationary charges cannot hold another charge in stable equilibrium in every direction, which is why the wire is needed in (a).)