Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 17 of 80
Three equal charges, each of magnitude +q , are placed at the three vertices of an equilateral triangle of side l .
Question 173 marksMedium
Three equal charges, each of magnitude +q, are placed at the three vertices of an equilateral triangle of side l. A charge Q (of the same sign as q) is placed at the centroid of the triangle.
(a) Using symmetry, argue what the net force on Q must be, without doing any vector calculation.
(b) Confirm your answer using the principle of superposition — explain briefly why the three individual forces on Q must sum to zero.
(c) The charge at one vertex is now removed. Without adding the two remaining forces as vectors, find the magnitude and direction of the net force on Q.
(a) The centroid is at the same distance from all three vertices, and the arrangement looks identical after a rotation of 120∘ about the centroid. If the net force pointed in some direction, rotating the whole picture by 120∘ would leave the charges unchanged but rotate the force — so the force would have to point in two directions at once. The only vector that is unchanged by such a rotation is zero:
Fnet=0
(b) Distance of the centroid from each vertex: r=3l, so each force has magnitude
F0=4πε01(l/3)2qQ=4πε0l23qQ
The three forces are equal in magnitude and 120∘ apart. Placed head to tail they form a closed equilateral triangle, so their sum is zero.
(c) Removing the charge at a vertex is the same as leaving it there and adding a charge −q at that vertex. The original three charges give zero force (part (b)), so the net force is just the force due to the "added" −q:
Fnet=F0=4πε0l23qQ
A −qattractsQ, so the force points from the centroid towards the empty vertex. (Check: the two remaining charges each push Q away from themselves, and their resultant indeed points towards the empty vertex.)