Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 78 of 80
Case Study: Laying an Oil Pipeline An offshore oil rig R stands 3 km out to sea from the nearest point P of a straight…
Question 785 marksHard
Case Study: Laying an Oil Pipeline
An offshore oil rig R stands 3 km out to sea from the nearest point P of a straight coastline. A refinery Q is on the coast, 8 km from P. A pipeline is to run in a straight line under the sea from R to a landing point L on the coast, and then along the coast from L to Q. Laying pipe costs ₹ 5 crore per km under the sea and ₹ 4 crore per km on land. Let PL=x km, where 0≤x≤8.
Attempt any four of the following five sub-questions.
(a) Express the total cost C(x), in crore rupees, in terms of x, and find C′(x).
(b) Find the value of x in [0,8] at which C′(x)=0.
(c) Find the least cost of the pipeline, justifying that it is the least value of C on [0,8].
(d) Show that, for the cheapest route, RLPL equals the ratio of the land cost per km to the sea cost per km.
(e) Suppose instead the refinery were only 3 km from P along the coast (all other data unchanged). Where should the pipe come ashore now, and what is the least cost? Justify your answer.
(a) Under the sea the pipe has length RL=9+x2 km; on land it has length LQ=8−x km. So
C(x)=59+x2+4(8−x),0≤x≤8C′(x)=9+x25x−4
(b)
9+x25x=4⇒25x2=16(9+x2)⇒9x2=144⇒x=4
(x=−4 is rejected since x≥0; x=4 does satisfy the unsquared equation, as 55⋅4=4.)
(c)C is continuous on the closed interval [0,8], so compare its values at the critical point and the end points:
The least of these is C(4)=41. (Also C′′(x)=(9+x2)3/245>0, confirming a minimum at x=4.)
The least cost is ₹ 41 crore, with the pipe coming ashore 4 km from P: 5 km under the sea and 4 km on land.
(d) At the cheapest route x=4 and RL=9+16=5, so
RLPL=54=sea cost per kmland cost per km
This is exactly the condition C′(x)=0 from (b): 9+x2x=54.
(e) Now C(x)=59+x2+4(3−x) on [0,3], with the same derivative C′(x)=9+x25x−4.
Its only zero, x=4, lies outside[0,3]. The function g(x)=9+x2x is increasing (as g′(x)=(9+x2)3/29>0) and g(4)=54, so for 0≤x≤3 we have g(x)<54 and therefore C′(x)<0.
So C is strictly decreasing on [0,3] and is least at x=3: the pipe should run straight under the sea from R to the refinery, with no land section.
C(3)=518=152≈21.21
The least cost is 152≈ ₹ 21.21 crore (compared with C(0)=27). Simply reusing x=4 here would be wrong, because that point is not on the coast between P and Q.