Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 14 of 80
Assertion: If x = at² and y = 2t, then . d² y/dx² t=2 = -1/16a². Reason: d² y/dx² = ( dy/dt )² × ( dt/dx )²
Question 141 markMedium
Assertion: If
x=at2andy=2t,
then
dx2d2yt=2=−16a21.
Reason:
dx2d2y=(dtdy)2×(dxdt)2
(A) Both assertion and reason are true and reason is the correct explanation of assertion.
(B) Both assertion and reason are true but reason is not the correct explanation of assertion.
(C) Assertion is true but reason is false.
(D) Assertion is false but reason is true.
Answer: (C) Assertion is true but reason is false.
Solution:
Step 1: Analyzing the Assertion
We need to compute the second derivative dx2d2y with respect to x at t=2.
We start by finding the first derivative dtdy and dtdx:
dtdy=dtd(2t)=2
dtdx=dtd(at2)=2at
Now, we can find dxdy using the chain rule:
dxdy=dtdxdtdy=2at2=at1
Next, to find dx2d2y, we differentiate dxdy with respect to x. Using the chain rule again:
dxd(dxdy)=dtd(dxdy)×dxdt
First, compute the derivative of dxdy with respect to t:
dtd(at1)=−at21
Now, compute dxdt by taking the reciprocal of dtdx:
dxdt=dtdx1=2at1
Now, apply the chain rule:
dx2d2y=(−at21)×2at1=−2a2t31
Finally, evaluate this at t=2:
dx2d2yt=2=−2a2(2)31=−2a2⋅81=−16a21
This is exactly the value stated in the assertion, so the assertion is correct.
Step 2: Analyzing the Reason
The reason states that:
dx2d2y=(dtdy)2×(dxdt)2
This is incorrect because the second derivative dx2d2y should not be computed in this way. The correct method involves differentiating dxdy with respect to x using the chain rule, as shown earlier.