The numbers , , satisfy . A student evaluates like this:
"By the addition formula, . Adding the last term, . So the sum is ."
Identify the true value of the sum together with the exact point at which this reasoning fails.
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 54 of 80
The numbers , , satisfy . A student evaluates like this:
"By the addition formula, . Adding the last term, . So the sum is ."
Identify the true value of the sum together with the exact point at which this reasoning fails.
(A) ; the reasoning is sound, since holds for all real and .
(B) ; the first step is fine, but the last step should read .
(C) ; the first step is invalid because , and for positive with the correct statement is .
(D) ; every term must be replaced by its supplement before the terms are added.
Option (C) is correct.
Each of , , is positive, so the sum cannot be ; the student's answer is impossible before any formula is checked.
The identity carries the condition , because the right-hand side always lies in while the left-hand side need not. Here , give : both and exceed , so their sum exceeds and no inverse tangent can equal it. For positive with the sum lies in and the correct form is
Hence
and adding gives
Numerically , confirming the value.
The same argument works in general: if and , then . Writing , , , the condition says exactly that , so is a multiple of ; since each of lies in , the sum lies in , and the only multiple of available is itself.