Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 37 of 80
When a ray of light passes from water into air, it bends away from the normal.
Question 375 marksMedium
When a ray of light passes from water into air, it bends away from the normal. If the ray meets the water surface at an angle of incidence i, measured from the normal with 0≤i<2π, the angle of refraction r in the air satisfies Snell's law
sinr=34sini
A laboratory program computes r=sin−1(34sini), using the principal value. For a ray passing from a certain glass into air the law reads sinr=2sini instead, and the program then uses r=sin−1(2sini).
Attempt any four of the following five sub-questions.
(a) A ray meets the water surface with sini=83. Find the angle of refraction r exactly.
(b) For some angles of incidence the program reports an error. Using the domain of sin−1, find all angles i with 0≤i<2π for which the water formula gives a value of r. Write the largest such angle (the critical angle for water) as an inverse sine.
(c) For the glass, find the critical angle exactly, and find the angle of incidence that produces an angle of refraction of 3π.
(d) A ray in water has i=sin−153. Show that its angle of refraction is r=sin−154, and hence show that i+r=2π.
(e) Show that r>i for every i with 0<i≤sin−143 in water. Then find the angle r−i through which the ray turns when it meets the surface exactly at the critical angle, as a single inverse trigonometric value.
(a) Here
sinr=34×83=21
and 21 lies in [−1,1], so r=sin−121=6π. This value lies in the principal branch [−2π,2π] and is a genuine angle of refraction between 0 and 2π.
(b)sin−1 is defined only on [−1,1]. Since sini≥0 here, the formula works exactly when
34sini≤1⟺sini≤43
On [0,2π) the sine function is increasing, so sini≤43 exactly when i≤sin−143. The program gives a value of r for
0≤i≤sin−143
and the critical angle for water is sin−143 (about 48.6∘). For any larger i the number 34sini exceeds 1, no angle has that sine, and the light is reflected back into the water. The program's error is the domain of sin−1 being exceeded.
(c) For the glass the formula needs 2sini≤1, that is, sini≤21, that is, i≤4π. The critical angle is 4π.
For r=3π:
2sini=sin3π=23⇒sini=223=46
so i=sin−146. Check: 46≈0.612 is less than 21≈0.707, so this angle is below the critical angle, as it must be.
(d)sini=53, and 53≤43, so the ray does refract. Then
sinr=34×53=54⇒r=sin−154
The acute angle whose sine is 54 has cosine 1−2516=53, so sin−154=cos−153. Hence
i+r=sin−153+cos−153=2π
since sin−1x+cos−1x=2π for every x∈[−1,1]. So for this ray the angles of incidence and refraction are complementary.
(e) For 0<i≤sin−143 we have sini>0, so sinr=34sini>sini. Both i and r lie in [0,2π], where sin−1 is increasing, so
r=sin−1(34sini)>sin−1(sini)=i
At the critical angle i=sin−143 we get sinr=34×43=1, so r=2π: the ray skims along the surface. The ray turns through