In a family census the ages, in whole years, are natural numbers. On define
which reads: person is exactly years older than person .
fails all three of reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity. Which set of counterexamples is correct throughout?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 25 of 80
In a family census the ages, in whole years, are natural numbers. On define
which reads: person is exactly years older than person .
fails all three of reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity. Which set of counterexamples is correct throughout?
(A) Not reflexive since ; not symmetric since but ; not transitive since but .
(B) Not reflexive since ; not symmetric since but ; not transitive since but .
(C) Not reflexive since ; not symmetric since but ; not transitive since but .
(D) Not reflexive since ; not symmetric since but ; not transitive since but .
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Read the rule carefully: means the first entry is the older one, .
Not reflexive. Take , which is in . Is ? No. So , and one failing element is enough. (In fact is impossible for every : nobody is years older than themselves.)
Not symmetric. , because . Its mirror would need , which is false, so .
Not transitive. We need two pairs that really are in and form a chain:
Transitivity would then force , which needs . False. So and transitivity fails. The gap has grown to years, and only ever records a gap of exactly .

Why the other options are tempting: