Option (B) is correct.
Step 1: count the partners of one square. Fix a square s, say (2,3). The squares in the same row or the same column as s are:
- s itself (it lies in its own row);
- the 3 other squares of its row;
- the 3 other squares of its column.
No square is counted twice: a square other than s cannot share both the row and the column of s. So each square is related to 1+3+3=7 squares.
Step 2: count the ordered pairs. There are 16 squares, each the first entry of 7 pairs:
∣R∣=16×7=112
Step 3: R is not transitive. (1,1)R(1,2) (same row) and (1,2)R(2,2) (same column), but (1,1) and (2,2) share neither a row nor a column, so ((1,1),(2,2))∈/R. So pairs must be added.

Step 4: the smallest transitive relation containing R. Call it T. Take any two squares s=(r1,c1) and t=(r2,c2). The corner square u=(r1,c2) is in the same row as s and in the same column as t, so
(s,u)∈Rand(u,t)∈R
Since T contains R and is transitive, (s,t)∈T. This holds for every pair (s,t), so T must be all of S×S. And S×S is transitive (it contains every pair), so it is the smallest transitive relation containing R:
∣T∣=16×16=256
Step 5: count the added pairs.
256−112=144
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) 0 would need R to be transitive already. Step 3 shows it is not.
- (C) 128=16×8 counts s twice for each square, once as a member of its row and once as a member of its column. The true count is 112, so 256−112=144 pairs are added, not 128.
- (D) 36 adds only the corner pairs one row and one column apart, like ((1,1),(2,2)). But every pair of squares in different rows and different columns must be added, for example ((1,1),(4,4)) through the corner (1,4). There are 16×9=144 such pairs.