Option (A) is correct.
Step 1: relations are groupings. An equivalence relation on A is fixed by its equivalence classes, and the classes here are exactly the groups. So we count the ways to split A into groups, each with at least two reagents.
Step 2: the possible group sizes. The sizes must add up to 5, and each size is at least 2.
- One group of 5.
- One group of 3 and one group of 2.
Any other split, such as 2+2+1 or 4+1, has a group of one reagent, which the rule forbids.
Step 3: count each type.
- One group of 5: there is only 1 way. This is the universal relation R=A×A.
- Groups of 3 and 2: choose the 3 reagents of the larger group in (35)=10 ways. The other 2 reagents form the second group.
1+10=11
Step 4: when is (1,2)∈/R? This happens exactly when reagents 1 and 2 are in different groups.
- In the single group of 5, they are together.
- In a 3+2 split, they are apart when the group of 3 contains exactly one of them. If it contains 1 but not 2, its other two members come from {3,4,5}: (23)=3 ways. If it contains 2 but not 1: again 3 ways.
3+3=6
Check: the other 10−6=4 splits keep 1 and 2 together. The group of 3 is {1,2,x} with x∈{3,4,5} (3 ways), or the group of 2 is {1,2} (1 way).
For example, the grouping {1,3,4},{2,5} gives
R={(1,1),(3,3),(4,4),(1,3),(3,1),(1,4),(4,1),(3,4),(4,3),(2,2),(5,5),(2,5),(5,2)}
which does not contain (1,2).
Why the other options are wrong
- (B) 52 is the number of all equivalence relations on a 5-element set. It ignores the rule that no reagent is stored alone, so it counts groupings such as {1,2,3,4},{5}. Likewise 37 counts every grouping with 1 and 2 apart, singletons included.
- (C) 5 counts the relations in which (1,2)∈R: the 4 splits from the check in Step 4, plus the single group of 5. The question asks for the opposite.
- (D) 10 forgets the single group of all five reagents. That grouping is allowed, because it has no reagent alone, and it gives the universal relation A×A.