Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 29 of 80
Given below are two statements — one labelled Assertion and the other labelled Reason.
Question 291 markMedium
Given below are two statements — one labelled Assertion and the other labelled Reason. Read the statements carefully and choose the option that correctly describes them.
Assertion: The relation R={(a,b):a2+b2=25} on the set of real numbers is a function.
Reason: In R, the number a=3 is paired with b=4 and also with b=−4.
(A) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is a correct explanation for assertion.
(B) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is not a correct explanation for assertion.
(C) Assertion is correct, reason is incorrect.
(D) Assertion is incorrect, reason is correct.
Answer: (D) Assertion is incorrect, reason is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1 — check the Reason, since it is a concrete claim about R. Substitute a=3:
32+b2=25⟹9+b2=25⟹b2=16⟹b=4 or b=−4.
Both (3,4) and (3,−4) satisfy a2+b2=25, so both belong to R. The Reason is true.
Step 2 — check the Assertion. For R to be a function on R, every real number a would need exactly one partner b. R fails this in two separate ways.
Some inputs have two outputs. Solving for b gives b=±25−a2, so whenever ∣a∣<5 there are two different values of b. The Reason exhibits this at a=3, and one such input is already enough to disqualify R.
Some inputs have no output at all. If ∣a∣>5 then 25−a2<0 and b2 would have to be negative, which is impossible for a real b. For instance a=6 gives b2=25−36=−11, so 6 is paired with nothing. A function on R must supply an output for every real input.
The Assertion is therefore false.
Step 3 — picture it.a2+b2=25 is the circle of radius 5 centred at the origin. A graph represents a function only if no vertical line meets it more than once. The vertical line a=3 cuts this circle twice, at (3,4) and (3,−4); the vertical line a=6 misses the circle altogether.
Step 4 — combine. Assertion false, Reason true. That is option (D).
Note what the Reason is not. It is not the general definition of a function; it is a specific, checkable fact about R. Reading it as a definition is the mistake to avoid — a Reason has to be judged as the sentence actually printed.