Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 18 of 80
A recurring-deposit scheme credits n³ rupees to an account in month n , for every n N .
Question 181 markMedium
A recurring-deposit scheme credits n3 rupees to an account in month n, for every n∈N. The credit is therefore the function f:N→N, f(n)=n3.
Assertion: This f is one-one but not onto.
Reason: The function g:R→R given by g(x)=x3 is both one-one and onto.
(A) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is a correct explanation for assertion.
(B) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is not a correct explanation for assertion.
(C) Assertion is correct, reason is incorrect.
(D) Assertion is incorrect, reason is correct.
Answer: (B) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is not a correct explanation for assertion.
Explanation:
Step 1 — Test the Assertion on N.
One-one. Suppose two months carry the same credit, f(n1)=f(n2). Then n13=n23. Taking cube roots of two equal positive numbers gives n1=n2, so no two different months can ever credit the same amount. f is one-one.
Not onto. The codomain is N, so the amount 4 rupees must be hit by some month if f is to be onto. But
13=1<4<8=23
and f is increasing, so any n with n3=4 would have to lie strictly between 1 and 2. There is no natural number there. Hence 4∈N has no preimage and f is not onto. (The same argument rules out 2,3,5,6,7 and so on — only perfect cubes are ever credited.)
The Assertion is correct.
Step 2 — Test the Reason on its own.
On R the cube is one-one, because x13=x23⇒x1=x2, and it is onto, because any real y is the image of the real number 3y. So g is indeed a bijection. The Reason is correct.
Step 3 — Does the Reason explain the Assertion?
No, and this is the heart of the question. The Reason is a fact about a different function: same formula, but domain and codomain R instead of N. Whether a map is onto depends on the domain and codomain, not on the formula alone. Worse, the Reason points the wrong way — it says the real cube is onto, whereas the Assertion says the natural-number cube is not onto. A true statement that supports the opposite conclusion is certainly not an explanation.
The contrast is exactly the one the chapter draws. On R the value 4 has the preimage 34≈1.587, which is a perfectly good real number but not a natural number. Restricting the domain to N throws that preimage away and breaks ontoness, while leaving one-oneness untouched.
On the graph, the horizontal line y=4 meets the curve once, at a point between x=1 and x=2 — a real input, but not a whole number of months.