Answer: (C) Assertion is correct, reason is incorrect.
Explanation:
Step 1 — Check the Assertion by testing all three properties on R={(1,1),(1,2),(2,1),(2,2)} over A={1,2,3,4}.
Symmetric? Go through the four pairs and look for the reverse of each.
| Pair in R | Reverse needed | Present? |
|---|
| (1,1) | (1,1) | yes |
| (1,2) | (2,1) | yes |
| (2,1) | (1,2) | yes |
| (2,2) | (2,2) | yes |
Every reverse is there, so R is symmetric.
Transitive? Every entry of R uses only the labels 1 and 2, and R contains all four ordered pairs that can be built from {1,2}. So whenever (a,b)∈R and (b,c)∈R, the elements a and c both lie in {1,2}, and therefore (a,c) is one of those four pairs and is in R. No chain can escape. So R is transitive.
Reflexive? Reflexive demands (a,a)∈R for every a∈A. But A contains 3, and (3,3)∈/R. (Likewise (4,4)∈/R.) So R is not reflexive.
All three claims of the Assertion hold. The Assertion is correct.
Step 2 — Where the Reason's argument breaks.
The chain of deductions in the Reason is, step by step, valid:
- from (a,b)∈R, symmetry does give (b,a)∈R;
- from (a,b)∈R and (b,a)∈R, transitivity does give (a,a)∈R.
But look carefully at what has been proved and what was wanted.
Proved: if a appears as the first entry of some pair in R, then (a,a)∈R.
Wanted: (a,a)∈R for every a in the set A.
The argument begins by assuming there already exists a pair (a,b)∈R. For an element that appears in no pair at all, the argument never starts, so it proves nothing about that element. Our machines 3 and 4 are exactly such elements: they are in A, but they are in no log entry, so nothing forces (3,3) or (4,4) into R.
That is not a subtlety about the wording — it makes the Reason's conclusion false as a general statement, and our own R is the counterexample: it is symmetric, it is transitive, and it is not reflexive. A single counterexample is enough. The Reason is incorrect.
Step 3 — Combine. Assertion correct, Reason incorrect — option (C).
The repaired statement. What is true is this: a symmetric and transitive relation R on A is reflexive on the set of elements that appear in at least one pair of R. Equivalently, a symmetric and transitive relation is always an equivalence relation on a possibly smaller carrier set — here, on {1,2}, our R is a perfectly good equivalence relation with the single class {1,2}. It fails to be one on A={1,2,3,4} only because two elements of A were left out entirely. Notice the parallel with the classic error of dropping a hypothesis: the Reason quietly assumes every element of A is used by R, and never says so.

In the digraph, 1 and 2 carry loops and a two-way arrow between them; 3 and 4 are bare dots with nothing touching them. The missing loops at 3 and 4 are precisely the missing reflexive pairs, and they are the elements the Reason's argument cannot reach.
A smaller way to see it. On A={1} take R=∅. The empty relation has no pair to break symmetry and no chain to break transitivity, so it is symmetric and transitive; but (1,1)∈/R, so it is not reflexive. This one-element example already kills the Reason.