Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 9 of 80
A lamp stands at the origin of a number line.
Question 91 markMedium
A lamp stands at the origin of a number line. The illumination it produces at the point x metres from the origin is modelled by f(x)=x21, so the domain of f is R−{0}.
Assertion: If only the codomain of f is changed, from R to (0,∞), the domain staying R−{0} and the rule staying f(x)=x21, then f becomes an onto function.
Reason: f(−2)=f(2)=41, so f is a many-one function.
(A) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is a correct explanation for assertion.
(B) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is not a correct explanation for assertion.
(C) Assertion is correct, reason is incorrect.
(D) Assertion is incorrect, reason is correct.
Answer: (B) Assertion is correct, reason is correct; reason is not a correct explanation for assertion.
Explanation:
Step 1 — Test the Assertion on its own.
Pick any target y in the new codomain (0,∞), so y>0. We must find an input in the domain that lands on it:
x21=y⟹x2=y1⟹x=y1
Because y>0, the number y1 is a real number and it is not 0, so it really does lie in the domain R−{0}. For instance y=9 is the image of x=31, and y=41 is the image of x=2. So every element of (0,∞) is used, and f is onto.
Why the old codomain failed: x2>0 for every x=0, hence x21>0 always. A value such as −4, or 0, is never an output. With codomain R those elements sat unused, so f was not onto. The range of f is exactly (0,∞), and shrinking the codomain to the range leaves nothing unused. The Assertion is correct.
Step 2 — Test the Reason on its own.
Both −2 and 2 lie in the domain R−{0}, and
f(−2)=(−2)21=41,f(2)=221=41
Two different inputs share one output, so f is many-one. The Reason is correct.
Step 3 — Does the Reason explain the Assertion?
No. Being many-one is about two inputs sharing an output. Being onto is about every element of the codomain being used. The two properties are independent, and this function shows it: after the restriction f is many-one and onto at the same time. So the Reason, true as it is, gives no ground at all for the Assertion.
In the lamp picture: points at equal distances on the two sides give equal illumination (that is the many-one part), while illumination is never zero or negative (that is what makes (0,∞) the right codomain).
The graph shows both facts together. The dashed line y=41 cuts the curve twice, at x=−2 and at x=2. Every dashed line drawn at a positive height cuts the curve somewhere, while a line at height 0 or below never touches it.