Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 45 of 80
Assertion (A): Hydration of pent-2-yne with dilute H₂SO₄ and HgSO₄ gives a mixture of two isomeric ketones, whereas…
Question 451 markMCQHard
Assertion (A): Hydration of pent-2-yne with dilute H2SO4 and HgSO4 gives a mixture of two isomeric ketones, whereas hydration of pent-1-yne under the same conditions gives essentially a single ketone.
Reason (R): In pent-2-yne both carbons of the triple bond carry alkyl groups (CH3 and C2H5), so the oxygen can end up on either of them; in pent-1-yne water adds according to Markovnikov's rule, so the oxygen goes to the internal carbon.
Select your answer
(A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
Correct answer
(B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(C) A is true but R is false.
(D) A is false but R is true.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
The Assertion is true. Water adds across the triple bond to give an enol, which changes at once into the more stable keto form. The carbonyl carbon is the carbon that received the –OH.
Pent-2-yne, CH3C≡CCH2CH3: the –OH can go to C2 or to C3. Both carbons carry an alkyl group, so neither position is strongly preferred, and a mixture forms:
Pent-1-yne, HC≡CCH2CH2CH3: by Markovnikov's rule the H goes to the terminal carbon (C1, which already has more H) and the –OH to C2, giving only pentan-2-one:
The Reason is true and explains the Assertion. The number of ketones depends on how many different carbons the oxygen can reach. Two alkyl-bearing carbons give two ketones; a terminal alkyne directs the oxygen to one carbon only.
The same idea explains why ethyne is the only alkyne that gives an aldehyde: in HC≡CH both carbons carry only hydrogen, so the carbonyl carbon keeps one H and the product is CH3CHO. Every other alkyne puts the oxygen on a carbon bearing an alkyl group and gives a ketone.
Why the others are wrong:
(B) would mean R is true but unrelated to A. In fact R is exactly why one alkyne gives two products and the other gives one.
(C) R is not false. Markovnikov addition to terminal alkynes is what gives methyl ketones.
(D) A is not false. Pent-2-yne is unsymmetrical (CH3 on one side, C2H5 on the other), so its two possible ketones are different compounds.