(a) Tollens' reagent oxidises all aldehydes, aliphatic and aromatic. Both compounds would give a silver mirror, so the test gives the same result for both.
(b) Fehling's test. Heat each compound with Fehling's reagent (equal volumes of Fehling solutions A and B).
- Phenylethanal: a reddish-brown precipitate of copper(I) oxide forms. Its CHO group is attached to a CH2 group, not to the ring, so it behaves like an aliphatic aldehyde.
- Benzaldehyde: no reddish-brown precipitate. Its CHO group is bonded directly to the ring, and NCERT states that aromatic aldehydes do not respond to Fehling's test.
C6H5CH2CHO+2Cu2++5OH−→C6H5CH2COO−+Cu2O↓+3H2O
