Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 31 of 80
An equimolar mixture of methanal and benzaldehyde is heated with concentrated sodium hydroxide solution.
Question 312 marksEasy
An equimolar mixture of methanal and benzaldehyde is heated with concentrated sodium hydroxide solution. Neither aldehyde has an α-hydrogen, and the reaction gives mainly one alcohol and one carboxylate salt (a crossed Cannizzaro reaction).
(a) Write the balanced equation for this reaction and name the two products.
(b) Work out the oxidation number of the carbonyl carbon in each aldehyde and of the same carbon in each product. Count each C–H bond as –1, each bond from C to O as +1 (a C=O counts twice) and each C–C bond as 0. Use the values to show which aldehyde is oxidised and which is reduced.
(a) Both aldehydes lack α-hydrogens, so with concentrated alkali they undergo the Cannizzaro reaction. Methanal, with no alkyl or aryl group, is the more reactive aldehyde: OH− adds to it, and it passes a hydride ion to benzaldehyde. So methanal ends up as the carboxylate and benzaldehyde as the alcohol:
HCHO+C6H5CHO+NaOHΔHCOONa+C6H5CH2OH
The products are sodium methanoate (sodium formate) and phenylmethanol (benzyl alcohol).
(b) Count the bonds on the carbon that changes in each compound.
Methanal, HCHO (two C–H, one C=O):
2(−1)+2(+1)=0
Methanoate ion, HCOO− (one C–H, one C=O, one C–O):
1(−1)+3(+1)=+2
Benzaldehyde, CHO carbon (one C–C, one C–H, one C=O):
0+1(−1)+2(+1)=+1
Phenylmethanol, CH2 carbon (one C–C, two C–H, one C–O):
0+2(−1)+1(+1)=−1
The methanal carbon rises from 0 to +2, so methanal is oxidised. The benzaldehyde carbon falls from +1 to –1, so benzaldehyde is reduced. The increase (+2) equals the decrease (–2), as it must in a redox reaction.