The rate at which ethanal forms its cyanohydrin with HCN is measured in buffered solutions. The reaction is very slow in strongly acidic solution (pH ≈ 1), even though acid protonates carbonyl groups. It is fast when a little base is present. HCN is a weak acid (). Which statement correctly explains this?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 70 of 80
The rate at which ethanal forms its cyanohydrin with HCN is measured in buffered solutions.
(A) In acid the carbonyl oxygen is protonated, which makes the carbonyl carbon less electrophilic.
- Correct answer
(B) In strong acid almost no is present, and neutral HCN is a very poor nucleophile; base converts HCN into , which adds to C=O, and the alkoxide formed takes from HCN, regenerating .
(C) Base increases the electrophilicity of the carbonyl carbon by removing a proton from ethanal.
(D) In acid, adds rapidly but the cyanohydrin decomposes at once, so no product is seen.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
Cyanohydrin formation is a nucleophilic addition, and the step that decides the rate is the attack of the nucleophile on the carbonyl carbon. The nucleophile that actually attacks is , which has a lone pair on a negatively charged carbon. Neutral H–C≡N attacks extremely slowly. NCERT: the reaction is very slow with pure HCN and is catalysed by base.
- pH ≈ 1: for HCN (), , so almost no is present. Protonating the C=O does make the carbon more electrophilic, but there is essentially no nucleophile to use it.
- Weakly basic: supplies . It adds to the C=O to form an alkoxide, which takes a proton from another HCN molecule. That step gives the cyanohydrin and a new , so only a little base is needed (it is a catalyst).

Why the other options are wrong:
- (A) is backwards: protonation puts a positive charge on the carbonyl group and makes the carbon more electrophilic. That is how dry HCl helps acetal formation.
- (C) Removing an α-H from ethanal gives a carbanion (the start of aldol chemistry); it does not make the carbonyl carbon more electrophilic, and it is not how base catalyses HCN addition.
- (D) In strong acid there is hardly any to add in the first place, and cyanohydrins are stable enough to isolate.
