Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 43 of 80
A mixture of ethanal and propanone is stirred with dilute sodium hydroxide at room temperature.
Question 431 markMCQHard
A mixture of ethanal and propanone is stirred with dilute sodium hydroxide at room temperature. Both compounds have α-hydrogens, so the mixture gives four β-hydroxy carbonyl compounds (aldol addition products).
Let X be the product formed when the carbanion from ethanal adds to the carbonyl group of propanone, and Y the product formed when the carbanion from propanone adds to the carbonyl group of ethanal.
Which option correctly names X and Y?
Select your answer
(A) X = 4-hydroxypentan-2-one; Y = 3-hydroxy-3-methylbutanal
(B) X = 3-hydroxy-3-methylbutanal; Y = 4-hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one
(C) X = 3-hydroxy-3-methylbutanal; Y = 4-hydroxypentan-2-one
Correct answer
(D) X = 3-hydroxy-2-methylbutanal; Y = 4-hydroxypentan-2-one
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation:
In an aldol reaction the base removes an α-hydrogen to give a carbanion. The carbanion carbon forms a new C–C bond to the carbonyl carbon of the other molecule, and that carbonyl oxygen becomes –OH.
X: ethanal carbanion + propanone. The carbanion is −CH2CHO. It adds to the carbonyl carbon of (CH3)2C=O:
The chain is numbered from the –CHO carbon (C1), so –OH and a methyl group are on C3: 3-hydroxy-3-methylbutanal. The product keeps the aldehyde group because the aldehyde supplied the carbanion.
Y: propanone carbanion + ethanal. The carbanion is −CH2COCH3. It adds to the carbonyl carbon of CH3CHO:
Numbering from the end nearer the C=O gives 4-hydroxypentan-2-one. The product is a ketone because the ketone supplied the carbanion.
The other two products of the mixture are the self-aldols: 3-hydroxybutanal (ethanal + ethanal) and 4-hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one (propanone + propanone).
Why the others are wrong:
(A) swaps X and Y. The compound that supplies the carbanion keeps its own carbonyl group, so X (from the ethanal carbanion) must still be an aldehyde.
(B) gives the correct X, but 4-hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one is the self-aldol of propanone (propanone carbanion + propanone), not Y.
(D) 3-hydroxy-2-methylbutanal, CH3CH(OH)CH(CH3)CHO, would need the carbanion CH3C−HCHO, which comes from propanal. Propanal is not present in this mixture.