Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 61 of 80
Ethanoic acid is heated with ethanol in the presence of a few drops of concentrated H₂SO₄ .
Question 618 marksHard
Ethanoic acid is heated with ethanol in the presence of a few drops of concentrated H2SO4. NCERT describes the reaction as a nucleophilic acyl substitution that goes through a tetrahedral intermediate.
(a) Write the mechanism in steps. In your answer name (i) the step that makes the carbonyl carbon more electrophilic, (ii) the nucleophile, (iii) the group that leaves and why it is able to leave. [3]
(b) A chemist uses ethanol labelled with the oxygen isotope 18O, that is CH3CH2–18OH. Using your mechanism, predict whether the 18O ends up in the ester or in the water. The labelled ester is then hydrolysed by refluxing with dilute acid. In which product does the 18O appear now? Justify both answers. [2]
(c) For this reaction Kc=4.0 at the reaction temperature. Calculate the percentage of ethanoic acid converted to ester at equilibrium when the starting mixture contains (i) 1 mol ethanoic acid and 1 mol ethanol, (ii) 1 mol ethanoic acid and 3 mol ethanol. State one other way of raising the yield. [2]
(d) Ethanal also forms a tetrahedral intermediate when a nucleophile adds to it, but it gives only an addition product, never a substitution product. Explain the difference. [1]
(a) Mechanism (four stages)
Step 1 – Protonation of the carbonyl oxygen.H+ from the acid catalyst adds to the C=O oxygen. The positive charge is shared with the carbonyl carbon, so the carbon becomes more electrophilic. This is the activating step (i).
Step 2 – Nucleophilic addition. The lone pair on the oxygen of ethanol (the nucleophile, ii) attacks the carbonyl carbon. The carbon changes from sp2 to sp3 and a tetrahedral intermediate forms.
Step 3 – Proton transfer. A proton moves from the oxonium oxygen of the added ethanol to one of the –OH groups, converting that –OH into –OH2+.
Step 4 – Elimination and deprotonation.–OH2+ leaves as a neutral water molecule (iii). OH− would be a poor leaving group, but H2O is a stable neutral molecule, so it leaves easily. The C=O bond re-forms, giving the protonated ester, which loses H+ to give the ester and regenerate the catalyst.
The ethanol oxygen is the atom that forms the new C–O bond in Step 2, and no step afterwards breaks the bond between that oxygen and the ethyl group or the carbonyl carbon. The oxygen that leaves as water comes from the acid's –OH group. So the label stays in the ester:
CH3COOH+CH3CH2–18OHH+CH3CO–18O–CH2CH3+H2O
The 18O is in the ester; the water is unlabelled.
Acid hydrolysis is the exact reverse of esterification. Water adds to the protonated ester, and the group that leaves from the tetrahedral intermediate is CH3CH2–18OH (as its protonated form). The acyl–oxygen bond breaks, not the ethyl–oxygen bond, so the 18O returns to ethanol, and the ethanoic acid formed is unlabelled.
(c) Equilibrium yield
Let x mol of ester form. At equilibrium: acid =1−x, alcohol =a−x, ester =x, water =x (the volume cancels because the numbers of moles on both sides are equal).
Kc=(1−x)(a−x)x2=4.0
(i)a=1:
1−xx=2⇒x=32=0.667
Conversion = 66.7%.
(ii)a=3:
x2=4(1−x)(3−x)⇒3x2−16x+12=0
x=616−256−144=616−10.58=0.903
(The other root, 4.43, is larger than 1 mol and is rejected.) Conversion = 90.3%.
Another way to raise the yield is to remove water as it forms (concentrated H2SO4 itself absorbs water), which pulls the equilibrium to the right.
(d) Addition versus substitution
In the tetrahedral intermediate from ethanoic acid, the carbon carries an –OH group that can be turned into –OH2+ and leave as water, so the C=O bond can re-form: the net result is substitution of –OH by –OC2H5. In the intermediate from ethanal the carbon carries only H and CH3, and H− and CH3− are extremely poor leaving groups. Nothing can leave, so the intermediate simply takes a proton and the reaction stops at addition.