Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 59 of 80
P, Q, R and S are four carbonyl compounds, each of formula C₅H₁0 O .
Question 591 markMCQMedium
P, Q, R and S are four carbonyl compounds, each of formula C5H10O. Their behaviour is summarised below.
Compound
2,4-DNP
Tollens' reagent
I2 / NaOH
Other observation
P
orange ppt
silver mirror
no ppt
with conc. NaOH gives an alcohol and a sodium carboxylate
Q
orange ppt
no change
yellow ppt
Clemmensen reduction gives 2-methylbutane
R
orange ppt
no change
no ppt
—
S
orange ppt
silver mirror
no ppt
with dil. NaOH gives a β-hydroxy aldehyde; Clemmensen gives pentane
Which option correctly identifies P and Q?
Select your answer
(A) P = pentanal; Q = pentan-2-one
(B) P = 2,2-dimethylpropanal; Q = 3-methylbutan-2-one
Correct answer
(C) P = 2,2-dimethylpropanal; Q = pentan-2-one
(D) P = 3-methylbutanal; Q = 3-methylbutan-2-one
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
P reduces Tollens' reagent, so it is an aldehyde. With concentrated NaOH it gives an alcohol and a carboxylate, which is the Cannizzaro reaction. Only aldehydes with no α-hydrogen do this. The only C5H10O aldehyde whose α-carbon has no hydrogen is 2,2-dimethylpropanal, (CH3)3CCHO:
2(CH3)3CCHO+NaOH→(CH3)3CCH2OH+(CH3)3CCOONa
Q does not reduce Tollens' reagent (a ketone) and gives iodoform (a methyl ketone, CH3CO–). Two C5H10O methyl ketones exist: pentan-2-one and 3-methylbutan-2-one. Clemmensen reduction replaces C=O by CH2 and keeps the skeleton, so a branched product, 2-methylbutane, needs a branched ketone:
Q = 3-methylbutan-2-one. For completeness, R is pentan-3-one (a ketone without CH3CO–) and S is pentanal (an aldehyde with α-hydrogens and an unbranched chain).
Why the others are wrong:
(A) Pentanal has α-hydrogens, so with alkali it gives an aldol, not Cannizzaro products; the table shows that S is pentanal. Pentan-2-one would give pentane, not 2-methylbutane, on Clemmensen reduction.
(C) identifies P correctly but uses the unbranched methyl ketone, which fails the Clemmensen clue.
(D) 3-Methylbutanal, (CH3)2CHCH2CHO, has two α-hydrogens, so it would undergo aldol condensation rather than the Cannizzaro reaction.