A chemist has a mixture of pentanal and pentan-3-one dissolved in ether. She shakes it with a saturated aqueous solution of sodium hydrogensulphite () and separates the two layers.
Which statement correctly describes what happens?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 1 of 80
A chemist has a mixture of pentanal and pentan-3-one dissolved in ether. She shakes it with a saturated aqueous solution of sodium hydrogensulphite () and separates the two layers.
Which statement correctly describes what happens?
(A) Pentan-3-one forms the water-soluble addition compound because its carbonyl carbon is more electrophilic; it is recovered from the aqueous layer with dilute acid.
(B) Both compounds form addition compounds to the same extent, so this treatment cannot separate them.
(C) Pentanal is converted largely into the water-soluble addition compound while most of the pentan-3-one stays in the ether layer; pentanal is regenerated from the aqueous layer with dilute acid or alkali.
(D) Pentanal forms the addition compound, but the addition is irreversible, so pentanal cannot be recovered from it.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1: which compound adds ? Sodium hydrogensulphite adds across the C=O group. NCERT states that the position of this equilibrium lies largely to the right for most aldehydes and to the left for most ketones, for steric reasons.
Step 2: where does each one go? The hydrogensulphite addition compound is an ionic salt and is water soluble, so pentanal moves into the aqueous layer as its adduct. Pentan-3-one stays in the ether layer.
Step 3: getting pentanal back. The addition is reversible. Treating the aqueous layer with dilute mineral acid or alkali converts the adduct back into pentanal. This is why NCERT describes the reaction as useful for the separation and purification of aldehydes.

Why the other options are wrong: