Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 6 of 80

Two patients, X and Y, swallowed the same volume of methanol by mistake.

Question 61 markMCQMedium

Two patients, X and Y, swallowed the same volume of methanol by mistake. Patient X was given intravenous infusions of diluted ethanol; patient Y was given only saline. A hospital recorded the following trends over the next 12 hours (hypothetical records):

ObservationPatient X (ethanol given)Patient Y (no ethanol)
Methanol in the bloodfalls slowlyfalls quickly
Methanoic acid in the bloodstays lowrises steadily
Methanol passed unchanged in urinelarge amountsmall amount

Which statement correctly interprets these records?

Select your answer
  • (A) Ethanol is oxidised by the same body enzymes, which it keeps busy; so X's methanol is converted to methanal and methanoic acid only slowly and much of it is excreted unchanged, which protects X even though methanol stays longer in the blood.

    Correct answer
  • (B) The faster fall of methanol in Y shows that Y is recovering better; the ethanol given to X has slowed the removal of the poison.

  • (C) Ethanol reacts with methanol in the blood to form a harmless ether, which is why methanol falls slowly in X.

  • (D) Ethanol, being a base, neutralises the methanoic acid formed in X, which is why little acid is detected.