(a) Expected diol: heptane-3,5-diol, CH3CH2CH(OH)CH2CH(OH)CH2CH3.
The ethyl group was meant to add to the –CHO carbon. This would give a new 2° –OH on C5 of a seven-carbon chain, alongside the 2° –OH already on C3.
It was not formed because a Grignard reagent is a very strong base as well as a nucleophile. It reacts with any compound that has an acidic hydrogen. The –OH group of Y is such a hydrogen, and this acid–base reaction is much faster than addition to the carbonyl group. The one mole of C2H5MgBr was used up in removing the –OH proton, so none was left to attack the –CHO group.
(b) The gas is ethane, C2H6.
Step 1 — the Grignard reagent takes the –OH proton:
CH3CH2CH(OH)CH2CHO+C2H5MgBr→CH3CH2CH(OMgBr)CH2CHO+C2H6
Step 2 — water protonates the magnesium alkoxide, which gives back Y:
CH3CH2CH(OMgBr)CH2CHO+H2O→CH3CH2CH(OH)CH2CHO+Mg(OH)Br

(c) Use at least two moles of C2H5MgBr per mole of Y (an excess), and add water only after both have reacted.
The first mole is sacrificed. It removes the –OH proton as in (b), and ethane is still given off. The second mole then finds no acidic hydrogen left, so it adds to the –CHO group:
CH3CH2CH(OMgBr)CH2CHO+C2H5MgBr→CH3CH2CH(OMgBr)CH2CH(OMgBr)CH2CH3
Hydrolysis frees both –OH groups:
CH3CH2CH(OMgBr)CH2CH(OMgBr)CH2CH3+2H2O→CH3CH2CH(OH)CH2CH(OH)CH2CH3+2Mg(OH)Br
The product is heptane-3,5-diol.
